In November 2022, 62-year-old James Driscoll Smith led Elko, Nevada police on a six-minute vehicle chase before crashing his truck into police vehicles and a tree. Smith was pulled from the wreckage and ended up lying facedown on the ground in the dark. Officer Brian Olvera struck him four times in the head with a baton, breaking one of Smith's arms and several of his teeth. Smith says his hands were stretched out at his sides at the time; Olvera claims one of Smith's hands was near his waist. Smith sued for excessive force, but on July 15, 2026, a divided three-judge panel of the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled 2-1 that Olvera is protected by qualified immunity, reasoning that no prior court case with nearly identical facts had "clearly established" that clubbing a facedown suspect in the head was unconstitutional. Judge Sidney Thomas dissented, writing that the court has repeatedly held police may only use head strikes when a suspect can reasonably be perceived as taking furtive or threatening action — and that whether Smith was doing so, or was simply incapacitated on the ground, is a factual dispute a jury should decide, not judges. Smith is now serving a prison sentence stemming from the chase itself; his attorneys have not said whether they'll seek a rehearing before the full appeals court.
 |
| Image by ChatGPT |
Commentary: The legal standard here is apparently that police can break your teeth with a club while you're facedown on the ground, and you can't even get in front of a jury unless you can produce a court ruling from the past declaring that exact scenario illegal — heads, batons, and all.
AI disclosure: ⚠️ This content was researched and written with AI assistance and may be fully AI-generated. All facts are sourced from the linked article and corroborating sources.
No comments:
Post a Comment